Over the past few months, I was a reporting intern for the business section of The Miami Herald. I didn’t blog during that time, mainly because I had no Internet access at home.
But I did want to post the essay I wrote for my independent study credit about the experience. It’s not meant to be a report of what went on — just what I learned. Especially if you’re a journalism student, I hope you read it. I learned more about what my future holds from this internship than from any class in my J-school.
When I was managing editor of the Alligator, one of our online producers posted a column our opinions editor had written.
All the producer had to do was copy the text from the column and paste it into the Web template. Yet somehow, our opinions editor was credited as “Andrew Wynn.”
Adam Wynn, obviously, was not thrilled.
“I’m beginning to question our institution,” he said.
At the time, I laughed. But over the 10 weeks of my internship at The Miami Herald, I thought back to that moment every day as I begin to question our institution.
I questioned our institution when 59 jobs were eliminated newsroom-wide, including long-time writers and editors who had made the Herald their entire career. I questioned our institution when the continuous news desk ignored a garbage truck hitting a major toll plaza for two days — writing a brief two days later when it was fixed. And I questioned our institution as a steady stream of people came by my desk and told me to go to law school.
My internship at the Herald was not, in many ways, ideal.
Four weeks into my internship, the next round of newsroom layoffs was announced. Three weeks later, they were implemented.
Those three weeks were tense and quiet. The silence was the most unnerving. A few rumors swirled, but nothing like what you would expect from a room full of journalists.
People talked about furloughs and discussed privately whose jobs they thought were in trouble.
Then the layoffs came, and everyone from secretaries to editors were crying in the bathroom.
Being an intern during that time was draining. I wasn’t completely a spectator, but I wasn’t participating either.
My job wasn’t at stake, and my career wasn’t on the line. As an editor darkly noted later, I didn’t even take a pay cut.
But I was watching my future collapse around me.
The mayhem was worse in the business department, which took some of the worst hits in the newsroom. Multiple editors took the buyout, and reporters and paginators took hits to their income, either through being cut to part-time hours or being laid off.
There wasn’t anything I could say to people to make it better, and I wasn’t really a part of their world.
Perhaps I had more of a vested interest than most interns. The Herald put bread on my table for about 15 years. My father worked there full-time as an editor and my mother freelanced. I had numerous fights with my sister, whenever my dad brought us to work, about whether we would take the elevator or escalator.
The layoffs were painful for me, but I knew, as everyone did, that I would be leaving after 10 weeks. I never had the mentality, as they did, that the Herald would always be there for me.
So I just tried to be unobtrusive, do my work, and not scream when the fifth person in a day came by my desk to say, “So, do you really want to do this?”
That’s not to say I didn’t get good experience.
I had no assigning editor, which left me swamped most of the time as editors tossed stories my way. But that’s just how the department worked, and I learned how to multitask as well as any reporter.
I covered the 68th Miami International Boat Show and Strictly Sail. I knew nothing about boats. I don’t particularly enjoy boating.
I learned more about boats in three weeks than I had ever thought possible. I wrote 50 inches for one boat show story, which is the second-longest piece I’ve ever written.
I got to write endless features, a few breaking news stories and several pieces I’m really proud of.
Honestly, I could never say that I enjoyed every second of my time at the Herald. But I got to work with wonderful people, and I learned more about the industry than I would have in a more sugar-coated newsroom.
Honestly, I could never say that I enjoyed every second of my time at the Herald. But I got to work with wonderful people, and I learned more about the industry than I would have in a more sugar-coated newsroom.
I still want to go into journalism, but I’ve realized that I might have to explore other options. During one, “why-don’t-you-go-to-law-school” interrogation sessions, I told a reporter that this was what I still wanted to do.
“Is this awful? Yes,” I said. “But not every day of my career will be like this.”
So I don’t have the bright-eyed innocence about journalism I once did. I’ve acknowledged that if I don’t have a job after graduation, I’ll take the LSAT and stop hating lawyers.
But I still love what I do, on the good days. I still get a rush out of deadline, and I still smile after a good interview.
If I question our institution, it’s because that’s what I’ve been trained to do.
If I question our institution, it’s because that’s what I’ve been trained to do.
I don’t have the answers. But I hope that we, as a profession, will figure them out so that I, and all the other journalists who still love what they do, can have a future.
14 responses so far ↓
paulbalcerak // April 15, 2009 at 2:15 pm |
That sucks that these so-called “professionals” would dissuade you from doing what you want to do just because they’re pissed off about losing their own jobs.
You just may become a lawyer at some point, but that doesn’t mean you can’t also be a journalist. The old guard is disappearing and while that’s sad to see, it’s also sad to see them kicking and screaming as they go, rather than fighting by innovating and helping by passing off their knowledge to the next generation.
You’re obviously smart enough to not let the experience completely turn you off to journalism. It’s probably good to become a little jaded before you leave college anyway. It’s rough out there (here), but there’s success to be had if you’re willing to work hard.
Hilary Lehman // April 15, 2009 at 2:27 pm |
While it was hard to hear reporters telling me to go to law school, I didn’t feel that it was out of bitterness.
The people who told me that had my best interests at heart, even if it wasn’t what I wanted to hear. If I had been a reporter for 30 years and had seen friends laid off and newspapers shrink, it might be hard to recommend the industry, too.
Everyone I worked with believed that journalism is still essential to today’s world — but the reporters on the ground aren’t the ones who can singlehandedly save journalism by innovation.
paulbalcerak // April 15, 2009 at 2:59 pm |
That’s good, and thanks for the clarification.
I should clarify, too, that I’m still employed and young (25), so it’s not like I’ve got a mortgage to pay and a kid to put through college. At the same time, I get tired of negativity. I came up through j-school with people warning me that the business was on the decline and I wasn’t going to make a lot of money—probably not the case with the generation before me—and I became a journalist anyway. So in a sense I knew all this was coming.
I don’t think “reporters on the ground” are going to save journalism with one good idea, but they can sort the good from the bad by trying things out.
I guess I’d just rather focus on the fact that this is a really exciting time and we all get to reshape journalism for the next several decades. I’ll think about doing something else if I get fired.
Sandy // April 15, 2009 at 3:02 pm |
I was going to go on a huge diatribe…but this might be more sobering….an interview series with various journalists on the future of journalism…god help us all.
http://www.ourblook.com/The-Media/The-Future-of-Journalism.html
Rebekah // April 15, 2009 at 3:58 pm |
The 50-inch feature you wrote about the boat show was an awesome article (and it totally helped me at my job – the PR for the boat show) Thanks again!
oh and just an FYI (I’m sure you know this) but it was the 68th Miami International Boat Show and Strictly Sail.
acturnage // April 16, 2009 at 7:21 pm |
I like Paul’s outlook. I’d recommend you read Charlie Beckett’s “Supermedia: Saving Journalism so It Can Save the World.” Obviously, it looks pretty bleak right now. But we journalists are a smart bunch, and if we go about it the right way, we’ll entually be able to squeeze some money out of this whole Internet thing.
Hilary Lehman // April 16, 2009 at 7:43 pm |
@acturnage,
Actually, I took Mindy McAdams’s class, where passages of that book were required reading. I have yet to finish it — in fact, I think it’s in my suitcase.
My thought, though, after being in a newsroom that is doing everything it can to innovate, is that we need to start looking past journalism innovations and to innovations in the actual business model.
It’s not so much the journalism that’s lacking, in my opinion — it’s the money we’re making off of it.
paulbalcerak // April 16, 2009 at 7:56 pm |
Sandy – To be frank, that post is a lot of hot air: “Papers should do both … charge for their content and work hard to get advertising on the site.” Go ahead and throw up a pay wall around your site—see what happens (also, I doubt there’s an ad department in the land that isn’t “working hard” to sell ads in any medium right now). The industry isn’t in great shape, but it’s got nothing to do with giving away content for free. Newspaper companies never made a significant amount of money off subscriptions anyway. Moreover, print is still a viable business venture.
Hilary hit on a very good point—”we need to start looking … to innovations in the actual business model.” Exactly. The journalists of the future will be journalist/businesspeople hybrids. The days of a fortified wall between the editorial side of a news company and the business side of a news company will have to come down if the industry is going to thrive again.
acturnage // April 16, 2009 at 8:56 pm |
I completely agree with you (that we need to look at innovations in the business model), but I wouldn’t say we need to look past journalism innovations themselves. We need to do both. That being said, I definitely think it would be a good idea to have students in J-schools in the future take some business/advertising classes as well.
Hilary Lehman: ‘Being an intern in unsure times’ | Journalism.co.uk Editors' Blog // April 17, 2009 at 4:30 am |
[...] Full post at this link… [...]
Katie // April 17, 2009 at 4:41 am |
Wow. This also happened to me while I was on work exp. in Lancaster, UK a couple of moths back. The sub-editing staff was cutby two-thirds, and since I left, the editing team and most of the reporters have lost their jobs too.
It was an awkward and unpleasant experience, like you said, you’re watching your future career collapse around you. People joked to me that perhaps I was getting myself into something I didn’t understand – maybe I should go back to school and learn how to be a teacher – but the truth is I still want this more than anything else, and I’m prepared to fight for it.
I really feel for those people who have been made redundant, but I’m perhaps naively optimistic that when the economy picks up again, journalism jobs will be in a greater supply once more. Until then I’ll be writing for free and gaining experience. It’s not a big change for me.
Hilary Lehman: ‘Being an intern in unsure times’ « DAILYMAIL.ME // April 18, 2009 at 3:04 am |
[...] Full post at this link… [...]
Links for today | Links para hoje « O Lago | The Lake // April 20, 2009 at 5:12 am |
[...] Being an intern in unsure times, Frustrations of a young journalist My internship at the Herald was not, in many ways, ideal. Four weeks into my internship, the next round of newsroom layoffs was announced. Three weeks later, they were implemented. Those three weeks were tense and quiet. The silence was the most unnerving. A few rumors swirled, but nothing like what you would expect from a room full of journalists. People talked about furloughs and discussed privately whose jobs they thought were in trouble. Then the layoffs came, and everyone from secretaries to editors were crying in the bathroom. Being an intern during that time was draining. I wasn’t completely a spectator, but I wasn’t participating either. My job wasn’t at stake, and my career wasn’t on the line. As an editor darkly noted later, I didn’t even take a pay cut. But I was watching my future collapse around me. [...]
‘My Future Collapse Around Me’ | NewsTechZilla // May 7, 2009 at 1:04 pm |
[...] by Trace Sharp Trace Sharp’s Website // Hilary Lehman writes of watching her future at a newspaper during very dark times. My internship at the Herald [...]